It has been common practice over
the years to preface any discussion of Gabonese history with remarks
as to how little has been written on the subject.[2]
If our scope were limited to published studies in English and in French,
we would have to conclude that the above remarks still apply. However,
we would be deceiving ourselves, as Gabonese researchers have been
producing unpublished mémoires de maîtrises and thèses
de doctorats in French universities since the late 1960s and, since
1982, they have been producing mémoires de maîtrises
in history at the Université Nationale Omar Bongo (henceforth
"UNOB") in Libreville. As a result there now exists a corpus of research
that foreign scholars are obliged to absorb during their time in country;
yet another item to add to an already crammed agenda.
Gabon, of course, is not unique
in this regard, as virtually all African countries have created similar
bodies of research. Access remains the problem for the foreign scholar
since these materials are rarely published or available outside their
country of origin. Annotated bibliographies, or bibliographical guides
of any kind, are to my knowledge extremely rare for materials of this
nature. Yet in the best of these studies, Gabonese researchers exploit
their language and cultural skills to conduct field interviews with
informants and thus create important new sources of historical data.
It is my contention that a systematic effort to work through these
locally-produced materials is indispensable to successful historical
research and that historians of Africa need to share information on
the research accomplishments of students and scholars in history departments
throughout the continent. In this way an aspect of "History in Africa"
that has been hitherto neglected will receive the attention it deserves.
This paper provides some background
on the development of scholarly research done by Gabonese on their
history, describes the present activities of the institutions in Gabon
that promote this research, evaluates mémoires de maîtrises
done at UNOB as to their usefulness to the foreign researcher, and
brings up to date information on archival and library resources in
Gabon. A bibliography of mémoires done in the History Department
at UNOB from 1982 to 1991 is provided in an appendix.
"Old Scrappers" and the First
Professionals
Not
surprisingly, the first Gabonese to write about their history were from
regions where European influence and missionary education had its earliest
and most pervasive influence. André Raponda-Walker is the most
noteworthy figure in this regard. The son of a British trader and a
Mpongwe woman related to the ruling families of the Estuary region,
Raponda-Walker became Gabon's first ordained priest in 1899. During
his active life in the church, he was posted to missions throughout
the colony and gathered information on the peoples with whom he came
in contact. He started publishing articles in French journals in the
1920s and on retiring in 1949, he began his collaboration with the ethnographer/
botanist Roger Sillans which led to the publication of joint works on
the uses of plants in Gabon and Gabonese religious practice[3]. He also
published his indispensable Notes d’histoire du Gabon during
this period.[4] He continued an active intellectual life up to his death
in 1968 at the age of 97. Though there exists an unpublished autobiography
and some commentary on his work, a full-blown biography of this man's
extraordinary life would be a very worthwhile project.[5]
Paul-Vincent
Pounah is another example of an "old scrapper'[6] who wrote on the history
of his ethnic group, the Galwa, in the days before there were any university-
trained Gabonese historians. Born in 1914 at Lambaréné, Pounah
served as a clerk in the colonial administration and was the most prolific
of several amateur historians who had bureaucratic careers but who were
also interested in documenting the past of their people. With the demise
of the precolonial clan structures and the creation of more cohesive ethnic
groups during the colonial and independence periods, these books, usually
published at the author's expense, played a key role in shaping contemporary
perceptions of ethnic identity.
In
Pounah's case, his view that the Galwa were related to the Myènè
speaking peoples of the coast clashed with Raponda-Walker's claim that
the Galwa were originally a branch of the Eshira ethnic group located in
the interior. Raponda-Walker posits that the Galwa simply adopted a Myènè
language in the nineteenth century as a consequence of their important
middleman position in the trade network stretching from the Orungu kingdom
on the coast up along the Ogooué river. The polemical exchange between
these "old scrappers" nicely illustrates the slipperiness of Gabonese ethnicity
and the complex roles played by language and history in the reformulation
of ethnic identities during the colonial era.[7] Pounah, who died in 1988,
stimulated other career bureaucrats to write similar works on their own
peoples. Sebastien Bodinga-bwaBodinga's short book on the oral traditions
of the Eviya is a typical and very useful example.[8]
The
first generation of professional Gabonese historians completed their training
at French universities in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Three men are
especially significant in this regard: Joseph Ambouroue-Avaro, Nicolas
Metegue-N'nah, and Anges Ratanga-Atoz. Ambouroue-Avaro, to my knowledge.,
was the first Gabonese to write a thèse de doctorat in history.
Originally from Port-Gentil, on obtaining his BAC in Libreville he received
a government scholarship to pursue university studies in geography and
history at the Sorbonne. There he was the student of Hubert Deschamps,
a former colonial governor but also the author of numerous works on African
history and, in the 1960s, an honorary professor at the Sorbonne.[9]
Ambouroue-Avaro's study of the peoples of the lower Ogooué region
in the nineteenth century was completed in Paris in 1969. It draws
on both oral and documentary sources and contains a number of key insights
on the evolution of the Orungu and Nkomi kingdoms. It was published with
no revisions in 1981, more than a decade after its completion and three
years after Ambouroue-Avaro's death. Yves Person provided a brief forward
to bring the work up to date. Despite the publishing delay, Ambouroue-Avaro's
book remained an original and stimulating contribution to Gabonese history.[10]
Sadly,
he was not able to develop his promising career as a scholar. While a student
in France, he apparently had some problems with the Gabonese regime and
lost his government scholarship; he completed his studies at his own expense.
Returning to Gabon in 1969, he taught at the secondary level and
at the Ecole Nationale d'Administration before joining the faculty at the
newly-created national university. However, he was subject to the harassment
of the Gabonese authorities due to his political views and was arrested
in 1972 and 1974. In 1975 he was appointed dean of the Faculté des
Lettres et Sciences Humaines at UNOB, but was forced to resign this position
in 1978 following a student strike. On 17 November 1978 Ambouroue-Avaro
died in a mysterious plane crash. Due to the very difficult conditions
he faced in Gabon and his tragic early death, he was never able to revise
his original doctoral thesis nor begin work on a thèse de doctorat
d'état that he was to write under the supervision of Catherine Coquery-Vidrovitch.
[11]
Nicolas
Metegue N'nah is from Lambaréné and nicely represents the
generational shift from the amateur to professional historian since Paul-Vincent
Pounah was his father-in-law. He began his studies in France at the Université
de Rennes and then came to Paris where he completed his doctoral thesis
in 1974 at the Université de Paris I on nineteenth-century contacts
between the French and Gabonese. Yves Person directed his research, but
Metegue-N'nah was also a student of Hubert Deschamps. His thesis relies
largely upon data drawn from French archival sources, but it is very thorough
and solidly argued. One wonders why it was never published. Metegue-N'nah
has published several shorter works of considerable interest to historians
of Gabon, but these are not so detailed or as carefully argued as his doctoral
thesis[12]
Metegue-N'nah
returned to Gabon in 1975, where he joined the faculty at UNOB and assumed
the chair of the Department of History. He held this position until 1982,
when he was linked to an opposition group critical of the Bongo regime
and forced to leave the university for a teaching post at a secondary school
in the town of Ndende in southern Gabon[13]. He taught in Ndende for several
years before returning to Libreville to take up a post at the Institut
Pedagogique National. In 1991 striking faculty at UNOB demanded that Metegue
N'nah and other academics forced out of the university in the 1980s be
allowed to return to their former positions. These demands were met and
Metegue N'nah resumed his place in the history department on the troubled
UNOB campus at the start of the 1991-92 academic year.
Anges
Ratanga-Atoz is from Port-Gentil and in 1973 he obtained a doctorat en
histoire from the Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes in Paris. His research
was directed by Henri Brunschwig and he wrote a thesis on Gabonese resistance
to French colonial rule. On returning to Gabon he was named an assistant
in the history department at UNOB, as well as the headmaster of a secondary
school in Libreville. In 1979 he took a position in a government ministry
and in 1982, still holding his position in the UNOB history department,
he assumed the direction of the Ecoles des Cadres du Parti Democratique
Gabonais (PDG), the training institution for the governing party of President
Omar Bongo. During the 1988-89 academic year, Ratanga-Atoz was head of
the UNOB history department. Since completing his doctoral thesis, he has
published a few articles and a brief, rather undistinguished, general history
of Gabon. [14]
Mention
should also be made of two Gabonese historians of this first generation
who came to the discipline through the priesthood: Florent Mbumb-Bwas and
Lazare Digombe. Mbumb-Bwas is from the Nyanga Region and he obtained a
doctorat d'université from the Université de Strasbourg in
1972, writing on the history of the Catholic Church in Gabon. He remains
an important figure in the Gabonese church and is the head priest at the
St. Michel parish in Libreville. Digombe, from the Ngounie region, did
university studies in France but subsequently left the priesthood. He was
a member of the history department at UNOB in the early 1980s before becoming
dean of the Faculté des Lettres et Sciences Humaines. In July 1991
he was appointed the Minister of Culture in the government of Prime Minister
Casmir Oyé Mba.[15]
The
careers of these five men illustrate some of the obstacles faced by Gabonese
historians who seek to pursue scholarly interests on completing their doctoral
research in France. In the case of Ambouroue-Avaro and Metegue-N'nah, their
links to opposition political groups and their criticism of the Bongo regime
prior to the opening up of the Gabonese political scene in 1990 effectively
destroyed their promising careers as scholars. Metegue-N'nah has tried
to carry on and is working on a general of history of Gabon, but has yet
to find a publisher. [16]
It
is fair to say that in the past the Bongo regime has been extremely suspicious
of intellectuals and in order to control them a two-pronged strategy was
developed: punish those who dared to dissent and reward those who were
willing to participate in the government. Ratanga-Atoz opted for the latter
route and today enjoys a position as conseiller à la Présidence
de la République. Despite the opening up of the political system
in 1990, this same suspicion continues to exist and the government uses
similar, though more subtle, tactics to keep intellectuals in check[17].
Yet, whether crushed in opposition or seduced by the ruling power, the
consequences for sustained research on Gabonese history by Gabonese scholars
remain the same: it simply does not happen. Thus most Gabonese historians
stop doing research on completing their doctoral theses in France and pursue
other interests when they return to Gabon to take up their university positions.
In
addition to the allure of politics, Gabonese scholars are confronted with
enormous obligations to members of their extended families, who have often
waited patiently for their return from France and who may have contributed
in one way or another to the completion of their studies. Having
assumed a position of prominence within Gabonese society as a professor
at UNOB, the Gabonese historian is often deluged with a variety of requests
from family members seeking to make use of their relative's situation to
advance their own interests. Dealing with these requests, in addition to
the inevitable bureaucratic duties of a university professor, obviously
cuts into time that might have been devoted to research. Yet even if the
historian is able to master the familiar balancing act between teaching
and administrative duties, meet family obligations, safely maneuver through
the minefields of Gabonese politics, and then somehow find the time to
formulate a research agenda, there is still one more virtually insurmountable
obstacle: the almost total lack of facilities and support for research
at UNOB.
The UNOB History Department and
the Eighties Generation
If
the nurturing of a national university is an indication of the strength
of a country's nationalist culture, Gabonese national culture is in need
of further nurturing.[18]. Gabon's national university first opened in
October 1970; following the initial investment to create the Libreville
campus the government did very little over the next twenty years to develop
or even maintain the university's facilities. The university library became
the most enduring symbol of this neglect: a specially constructed building
designed for air-conditioning (windows do not open), when I worked there
in 1991 the air-conditioning had not functioned for over a year. It was,
to say the least, an uncomfortable place to work. The card catalog no longer
corresponded to anything in the collection (indeed, the collection had
been decimated due to theft and neglect) and the staff was understandably
dispirited. Fortunately, faculty strikes in 1991, partly organized around
the terrible working conditions at UNOB, resulted in some major remodeling
work on the library. It remains to be seen if the collection will be improved.
The
lack of library facilities is only one of the obstacles facing the Gabonese
historian wanting to continue to do research in Gabon. Faculty do not have
offices at UNOB, nor are they necessarily provided with working space on
campus. The history department has a small library which is staffed by
masters degree students; in 1991 half this space served as the office for
the chair of the department. Due to the faculty strike and the closing
of the university in May 199 1, it was rarely open the remainder of the
year.[19] I am well aware that infrastructure problems, lack of government
support, political tensions, and mismanagement of existing resources plague
universities throughout Africa to a greater or lesser degree. In Gabon
the picture is perhaps unnecessarily bleak given the relative wealth of
the country; I raise these issues to explain why Gabonese historians neither
publish nor produce much research after completing their doctorates.
Despite
some hopeful developments, this is the discouraging state of affairs that
holds for the generation of Gabonese historians who completed their théses
pour le doctorat de 3e cycle at French universities in the 1980s. The production
of doctoral theses that rely almost entirely on data gleaned from French
archival sources reached its peak in this second generation. This was a
curious phenomenon, as Gabonese historians are clearly the best-equipped
researchers (due to their language and cultural skills) to gather historical
data from oral sources in their own country. Yet until the development
of the mémoire de maîtrise at UNOB in 1982, there was little
chance for Gabonese students of history to do any systematic oral research.
Once in France, there existed very few funding opportunities to return
to Gabon to do field research. Thus the most efficient way to complete
a doctoral program was to work with archival material. This archival focus
also reflected the research interests and preferred methodology of the
French historians directing Gabonese students' research in the 1970s and
1980s[20]
C.
Felix Painbo-Loueya's doctoral thesis on the social and economic history
of the Gabon colony during the interwar years is a case in point. Completed
in 1980 at the Université de Paris VII under the direction of Catherine
Coquery-Vidrovitch, it is two-volume study of 691 pages that successfully
organizes a large amount of information under the broad headings of "structures
sociales économiques et politiques," "production," and "déséquilibres
et inadéquation de l’économie coloniale". Indeed, it is very
much in the tradition of Coquery-Vidrovitch's classic study on French concession
companies; its length gives it more the flavor of a thése d'État
than a thèse de 3e cycle. It is valuable research that deserves
to be published; but once again the obstacles referred to above come into
play, as Pambo-Loueya, a member of the UNOB history department throughout
the 1980s, has held positions in government, and has apparently been unable
to either find a publisher, rework some of his material into journal articles,
or undertake the necessary revisions to produce a publishable manuscript.[21]
There
seems to be a "more is better" attitude taken by Gabonese historians when
writing their doctoral theses. This is due to a stubborn "thèse
d’État" mentality that continues to exist in French academia (despite
the forthcoming disappearance of the thèse d’État itself)
and that seems to push researchers into producing unwieldy, difficult to
publish tomes. The most successful, like that of Pambo-Loueya, are worth
the time and effort of a close reading. Others can be more frustrating
to work through and are little more than compilations of tables and facts
drawn from colonial reports pieced together in a less than lucid fashion.[22]
A
singular exception to this tradition of theses based on archival research
is Monique Koumba-Manfoumbi's fascinating study, completed in 1987 at
Université de Paris 1, on the history of the Punu people of southern
Gabon[23] She has compiled a rich collection of Punu clan migration accounts
and has charted the peopling of the Punu-speaking areas of southern Gabon
according to clan movements. She gathered these clan traditions from interviews
with close to fifty informants, overcoming considerable logistical obstacles
simply to reach certain villages. To obtain this information she was required
to conduct complex negotiations with clan elders who were reluctant to
share specialized knowledge with a young female researcher. Yet to one
who has attempted to gather oral data in this same region of Gabon, KoumbaManfoumbi's
results are very impressive, and her research should be published. But
the same pattern is again at play; since returning to Gabon and taking
a position at UNOB Koumba-Manfoumbi has apparently fallen into the scholarly
black hole[24].
Until
recently any Gabonese scholar completing a doctorate in France was assured
of a position at UNOB on returning home. This was due to the fact that
when the university opened in 1970 there were very few Gabonese with higher
degrees and many positions were simply waiting to be filled by the first
returning doctorates. A consequence of this initial shortage of Gabonese
faculty is that the university has traditionally been staffed by significant
numbers of expatriates. The history department has been no exception: Catherine
Coquery-Vidrovitch was present for a time in the early 1970s; the Malian
historian, Sékéné Mody Cissoko, has taught at UNOB
for a number of years; and Aliké Tshinyoka, a Zairian classics scholar,
was head of the department at the time of my research in 1991. Raymond
Mayer, a French anthropologist, and Hugues de Changy, a French historian,
have been teaching and directing research in history at UNOB for more than
a decade. The 1980s generation of doctorates has since filled in most of
the gaps and at present there is little room for new blood. Gabon's economy
has been on the downturn since 1985 and this situation will not allow for
an inflation of the university ranks[25]
Ironically,
the opening up of the Gabonese political system to opposition political
parties and a critical press has resulted in a further deterioration of
university life, as educational institutions, and particularly the university,
have been used as ideological battlegrounds by both the government and
the opposition. Since the student disturbances of January 1990, UNOB has
more often than not been closed due to either striking faculty or striking
students[26] Obviously such instability precludes, and renders somewhat
absurd, the possibilities for a vibrant scholarly environment. Yet prior
to this recent outbreak of political unrest, there had been some new developments
to give heart to those interested in historical research on Gabon.
Laboratoire
Universitaire de la Tradition Orale
The
Laboratoire Universitaire de la Tradition Orale (hencefoarth LUTO) was
created in 1985 and at the end of the 1986-87 academic year it launched
a series of projects seeking to collect, transcribe, and publish the myths,
epics, and historical traditions of the Gabonese people. It brought together
scholars from a number of disciplines and was clearly an attempt to fill
the research void that existed at UNOB. There were a number research teams
created, Pambo-Loueya and Cissoko from the history department were responsible
for collecting historical traditions, and plans for conferences and publications
were put in motion.[27].
When
I met with Michel Voltz, a French anthropologist and the Secretary General
of LUTO in April 1991, he expressed frustration that LUTO had not
effectively met its goal of promoting research in the humanities at UNOB.
He noted, among other things, the difficulty of publishing research in
Gabon due to high costs and few presses. For example, the first two issues
of the Revue Gabonaise des Sciences de I'Homme, a LUTO publication,
had to be printed in Portugal. A project to collect village histories from
all the regions of Gabon, designed for eventual use in Gabonese secondary
schools, has gathered enough material for two volumes but remains unpublished.
Several historians, Parnbo-Loueya and Koumba-Manfoumbi among them, have
contributed to these volumes. Once again, the problem of gaining access
to publishing outlets not only keeps completed research from seeing the
light Of (lay but also dampens the desire to continue producing new material.[28]
The instability and strikes that have plagued UNOB over the past three
years have resulted in the shutdown of LUTO's activities as well.
Student
Research in the History Department at UNOB
The
most valuable research on Gabonese history coming from the university
community is done by students. It is especially valuable to foreign researchers,
as Gabonese students already have the language and cultural expertise to
do oral research that would take non-Gabonese years to develop. In an indirect
manner these student researchers become a new kind of interpreter for the
foreign researcher; the questions they pose and the materials they produce
are their own and obviously not guided by the interests of an outsider.
Yet there is much that is interesting in the results, as even the most
shoddy work reveals something about the students' attitude toward the past
and toward their informants. Better work allows the informants' worldview
to come through and a good deal of what Gabonese students have done over
the past ten years is of this caliber.
As
we have seen, the first Gabonese to receive university training in history
produced mostly archive-based research. This situation began to change
in 1982 as Gabonese students pursuing history at UNOB started to
go into to the field on a regular basis to collect oral data to write their
mémoires de maîtrise. The creation of a maîtrise-level
degree to be completed in Gabon was the crucial development. The first
two generations of Gabonese historians received virtually all of their
post-secondary school training in France. This was, of course, due to the
fact that UNOB was created in 1970 and only began awarding degrees at the
licence level in 1977.[29] There were no opportunities to do historical
research in Gabon at the university level until 1979,
when the first
mémoires de licence began to appear. A number of these early efforts
treated non-Gabonese topics or were merely exercises in working with colonial
archival material available in Libreville. When students did seek to obtain
oral data from informants, no more than a handful were interviewed and
there were no apparent guidelines as to how this material was to be collected
or presented.[30]
In
1982Lazare Digombe, at the time a member of the UNOB history department,
pushed his colleagues to adopt a more structured program of student research
that emphasized collecting oral data from informants. Students were required
to spend several weeks in the field gathering material; this was most often
accomplished over the holiday break in January.[31] As the program developed,
students tended to work on a particular topic over several years and to
make more than one trip into the field. A preliminary paper, the mémoire
de D.U.E.L., has become the first step in undertaking research, usually
written at the end of a student's second year at university. The mémoire
de license, originally a finished product in itself, has evolved into an
elaboration of ideas presented in the preliminary paper, a summary of initial
field research, and a research proposal for the mémoire de maîtrise.
The mémoire de maîtrise often involves additional field work
and the finished product is usually a study of more than 100 pages. The
most talented students go on to France to develop their research in doctoral
programs further.
Koumba-Manfoumbi
is one of the first to have gone through the mémoire de maîtrise
program and then complete a doctorate in France. It is certainly no coincidence
that data gathered from informants in oral field interviews were at the
core of her thesis.[32] Another recent and highly regarded study is Wilson-André
Ndombet's history of the Adjumba people. Ndombet completed his doctorate
in 1989 at Paris I but he had been able to collect data in the field while
at UNOB and develop his topic in preparing a mémoire de licence
and a mémoire de maîtrise before going to France in 1985.[33]
Clearly, this situation is a vast improvement over the days when Gabonese
researchers were obliged to make archival material the primary focus of
their studies.
But
what of the usefulness of these mémoires to the foreign researcher?
After all, these studies are the efforts of students undertaking a research
project for the first time. Naturally the final product at this level will
tend to be a bit rough. Given the woeful library situation, up-to-date
journals and recent monographs that might aid the students' in organizing
and interpreting their data are extremely difficult for even a professor
to obtain and virtually impossible for a student. Students are further
limited by a "Francophonie mon village!" world view that results in their
being unaware of scholarship produced in English[.34] Having read through
a number of these mémoires for my own research on the history of
southern Gabon, I can attest to their uneven quality.
In
the appended bibliography, I have grouped the mémoires de maîtrise
done at UNOB from 1982 to 1991 into eight categories. One notes a healthy
representation of studies on various aspects of French colonial administration
viewed from the perspective of the colony as a whole. These tend to he
based on data drawn from colonial archives housed in Gabon. The histories
of individual Catholic missions, due to their more specific focus and the
fact that virtually all the mission archives are in France, tend to rely
more on informants.[35] But the majority of the mémoires can be
grouped into two categories: ethnic group histories or town and regional
histories. The latter usually combine information drawn from colonial political
and economic reports with oral data obtained from informants who relate
their life experiences under colonial rule. These studies are valuable
sources on the development of colonial towns, regional economies, and the
evolution of local political authority, as well as life under colonialism.
[36]
Those
mémoires focusing on the history of an ethnic group are the most
interesting in terms of oral data. Some are very much in the tradition
of "old scrappers" like Pounah and seek to legitimate the existence of
ethnic identities forged during the colonial period. It is revealing that
a number of these studies are on "disappearing" peoples like the Adjumba
and Eviya, whose numbers are dwindling due to the rural exodus to towns
and cities and the traditionally fluid boundaries of ethnicity in Gabon.[37]
The most interesting raise provocative questions about the creation of
ethnic identities and seek to explain the relationship between ethnicity
and clan. Charles Mombo-Maganga's study of the history of the Varama is
an example; his mémoire de maîtrise contains rich data on
Varama clan migrations and the functioning of the precolonial clan system.[38]
In preparing a proposal for his doctoral thesis in France, MomboMaganga
shifted his focus from the Varama ethnic group to examine the rise of the
dominant clan among the Varama, the Gimondu. Branches of this clan, though
under different names, are present in several other ethnic groups in southern
Gabon.[39] It is in analyzing the changing role of the precolonial clan
system in face of increased ethnic awareness during the colonial period
that one hits on the major theme in recent Gabonese history.
The
ethnic group studies that I read through while in Gabon left me with the
impression that students were following guidelines from the supervising
professor in order to organize their research. The mémoires are
usually divided into three parts: the first part covers origins and migrations;
a second part describes social, economic, and political structures as they
existed in the nineteenth century just prior to colonial rule; and a third
part describes colonial occupation and the alteration of the precolonial
structures. Clearly what we have here is the latest manifestation of the
classic "ethnographic account" genre analyzed by Jan Vansina.[40] According
to Vansina,
The
genre requires that a description be given by rubric without any progression
of argument, without any flow from point of departure to final consideration,
except for what is provided by the arrangement of rubrics. Chapters or
major sections deal with material culture, food producing activities, industries,
kinship and domestic organization including marriage, political organization,
religion, magic and (more optional) ethics, language, oral art, arts and
sciences. This is the most common order.[41]
The
second part of the ethnic group mémoires nicely mirrors this description.
It is ironic, though not surprising given limited access to recent scholarship,
that Gabonese students should make use of a decidedly colonial genre to
research and write the nineteenth century precolonial history of their
peoples. The better studies do break from the timelessness of the ethnographic
account and insert some historical narrative. This is invariably found
in the third part where the specific events of colonial occupation and
resistance are discussed.
Vansina
raises a number points regarding rules of evidence and the sources of data
found in the earlier colonial versions of the ethnographic account genre.
These are legitimate concerns for the twentieth-century Gabonese examples.
Yet, by and large the Gabonese students have been meticulous in citing
their sources and including lengthy appendices of the transcriptions of
their taped recordings with informants (the recordings themselves remain
in the possession of the individual researchers as there is no audio archive
for this material). Since the mid-1980s, at the instigation of the anthropologist
Raymond Mayer, students have been required to provide transcriptions of
their interviews in the Gabonese languages in which they were conducted
with a French translation along side[42] They have always provided
information about their informants, usually including name, age, profession,
ethnic group, clan, and place of residence.
Ultimately,
these appended lists of informants and transcriptions of interviews are
the parts of the mémoires de maîtrise most valuable to foreign
researchers. The informant information is enormously practical as one can
use it to draw up one's own list of possible interviews before heading
into the interior. The students usually begin their studies with a brief
description of their field experiences and these can be quite helpful as
well.[43] The data found in the interview transcriptions has the advantage
of being raw and untouched by concerns of fitting it into the text of a
mémoire. Thus, for another researcher with a different set of questions,
this material holds the possibility of further insights and new information.
Occasionally, as is the case with Hortense Togo's study on the oral traditions
of the Apindji, the annexed material is nearly as long and just as interesting
as the mémoire itself.[44].
Therecent
political problems in Gabon and at UNOB have slowed, and at times brought
to a halt, the normal operation of the university and this has naturally
affected student research. However, given the obstacles faced by senior
scholars outlined above, the most interesting material on Gabonese history
may continue to be produced by Gabonese university students for some time
to come.
Archives
and Other Sources of Documentation
The
earlier archival reports of Hubert Deschamps[45] and Henry Bucher[46] are
still useful starting points when preparing to work in Gabon. Though Deschamps
wrote more than thirty years ago, his description provides a sense of perspective
on what has been accomplished, and what has been lost, in the intervening
period. The accomplishments, mainly the creation of a national archive
and a national library, are described in Bucher's report and were primarily
due to the efforts of their first general director, Gaston Rapontchombo.
The losses are at the level of regional archives since, though there have
been efforts to transport and classify documents languishing in the interior
to Libreville, not all of the provincial centers have been reached .[47]
The
Archives Nationales (B.P. 1188, Libreville, tel. 73 02 39) are open
Tuesday thru Friday, 7:30AM to noon, 3:OOPM to 6:OOPM; and on Saturday,
7:30AM-1:00PM. They close one month out of the year for inventory (usually
in August/September); student or faculty identification is needed for admission.
The archives are divided into two main sections. The first holds the paper
copies of French colonial documents specific to the various regions of
Gabon; these are consulted in the lower level of the archive-library complex
by using the "Fonds de la Présidence" card catalog, which is classified
according to rubric (e.g., "Rapports politiques," "Santé," "Travaux
publics," etc.), and by consulting several bound catalogs classifying documents
from regional archives and special collections.
The
main development since Bucher's report has been the growth of the microfilm
holdings. The microfilm archivist spends six months out of the year in
France at the Archives Nationales, Centre des Archives d'Outre-Mer in Aixen-Provence
microfilming material relevant to Gabonese history. As a result foreign
researchers can now get much of their archival work accomplished while
in Gabon.[48] The microfilm readers are in good condition, but the archive
does not own a machine that makes photocopies from film (though there are
plans to purchase one). Photocopying of hard documents is possible but
expensive at about 30 cents per copy. This is conditional on the state
of the archive's only copier, which can be down for long periods.
The
Bibliothèque Nationale is housed in the same complex as the Archives
Nationales. It is open Tuesday thru Friday, 7:30AM to 6:OOPM; and Saturday,
7:30AM to 1:00PM. The reading room is a pleasant place to work, as it is
cooled by ceiling fans and looks out on the Gabon Estuary; but more important
is the fact that it remains open all day and one can work through the long
Gabonese lunch break. The library has a good, though not exhaustive, collection
of Gabonese mémoires de maîtrise, as well as a selection of
doctoral theses done in France. By consulting the main and the history
department libraries at the university in addition to the Bibliothèque
Nationale, one gains access to virtually all the unpublished research done
by Gabonese students at UNOB. The photocopying situation is the same as
for the archives.
The
tense political situation has not spared this sector: archive and library
personnel went on strike in April 1990 to demand General Director Rapontchombo's
retirement. There were reports of theft and sabotage though I did not notice
any permanent damage a year after these events .[49] Following the strike's
resolution, Fidèle lbouili-Nzigou, a member of the psychology department
at UNOB, was named General Director and Rapontchombo was subsequently named
conseiller à la Présidence de la République.
Only
once did I visit the small library at the Libreville Chamber
of Commerce mentioned by Bucher and I was unable to find the document I
was looking for; however a recent Indiana University Ph.D. thesis on Gabonese
agricultural policy made use of this facility.[50] There is no longer an
ORSTOM office in Gabon, but the small museum library still exists.
It has moved from its space in the Musée National des Arts et Traditions
to an annex building located in the heart of Libreville's largest market,
Mont Bouet. The library reading room is open Monday thru Friday, 8:OOAM
to noon; 3:OOPM to 6:OOPM.
Libreville
is home to the Centre International des Civilisations Bantu (CICIBA), an
ambitious project designed to promote research on the Bantu world in the
fields of archeology, ethnomusicology, linguistics, and traditional medicine.
Though the Center's interests deal with historical questions and its first
director, Théophile Obenga, is a historian, there is no history
section within its structure. A pet interest of Gabonese President Omar
Bongo, CICIBA's fortunes have declined along with those of the Gabonese
economy and the center has found it difficult to meet its development agenda.
Housed in a temporary site for the nearly ten years of its existence, a
permanent facility on the outskirts of Libreville remains three-quarters
complete and unoccupied due to lack of funds. The much-vaunted computer
network meant to link centers in member countries and to serve as a clearinghouse
for information on the Bantu world does not function effectively. There
is a library at the temporary site but it contains very little material
on Gabonese history; books and other materials on microfiche reflect CICIBA's
regional Bantu focus. Obenga, a Congolese national, returned to Brazzaville
in 1992 to assume a cabinet position in the Congolese government (which
he promptly lost with the creation of a new government at the end of the
year). In January 1993, he was replaced as General Director of CICIBA by
Koukanda Vantomene, an Angolan national[51].
The
most interesting addition to Libreville's research scene has been the development
of an outstanding collection of historical materials on Gabon at the library
of the Centre Culturel Franqais St. Exupery (B.P. 2103, tel. 76 11 20;
open Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday, 10:OOAM-noon; 3;30PM-6:30PM; Wednesday,
8:30-noon; 3;30PM-6:30PM; Saturday, 10:OOAM-noon; 4:OOPM-6:OOPM; closed
the month of August; admission with a reader's card that must be obtained
from the librarian; fee for foreign researchers about $20). Annie Merlet,
the head librarian at the Center for a number of years, obtained funding
to purchase or photocopy rare books and articles relevant to Gabonese history
found in France. She organized all this material into a collection labeled
"Fonds Gabon" and it is probably the best collection of historical documents
related to Gabon under one roof anywhere in the world. She has drawn from
this collection to publish a series of books on Gabonese history which
are primarily collections of relevant excerpts from difficult to find explorers'
accounts [52]
When
Merlet was still at the Center, one had to make an appointment with her
to consult the "Fonds Gabon" as it was kept in her office separate from
the general collection. This was sometimes difficult, as she was very busy
and often using the collection herself. She left Gabon in July 1991. 1
met with her replacement shortly after he assumed the head librarian position
in September and he stated that he had absolutely no interest in the "Fonds
Gabon." Apparently, Merlet did not train any of the permanent staff to
maintain the collection nor did she appoint any one to monitor its access.
As a result, the future of this valuable resource is in jeopardy.
Notes
I.
My research in Gabon was made possible by a Predissertation Research Grant
from the Social Science Research Council in June 1989 and by a Fulbright-Hays
Doctoral Dissertation Research Fellowship from the U.S. Department of Education
in 1991. 1 would like to thank John Cinnamon of Yale University for his
comments and suggestions.
2.
See the prefatory remarks in Phyllis M. Martin, The External Trade of
the Loango Coast 15760-1870 (Oxford, 1972), vii; and K. David Patterson,
7he
Northern Gabon Coast to 1875 (Oxford, 1975), vii. For a more recent
statement, see the "Avant- Propos" in Nicolas Metegue N'nah, Lumiére
sur points d'ombre (Langres, 1984), 11.
3.André
Raponda-Walker and Roger Sillans, Les plantes utiles du Gabon (Paris,
1961);Rites et croyances des peuples du Gabon (Paris, 1962).
4.Raponda-Walker,
Notes
d'histoire du Gabon (Mémoire de l'Institut d’Études Centrafricaines,
9). (Brazzaville, 1960).
5.
Biographical information can be found in David E. Gardinier, Historical
Dictionary of Gabon (Metuchen, 1981), 194; there is a "bio-bibliographie"
in Hubert Deschamps, Traditions orales et archives au Gabon (Paris,
1962), 161-67; and nearly three pages of references in the bibliography
to Henry H. Bucher, "The Mpongwe of the Gabon Estuary: A History to 1860'
(Ph.D., University of Wisconsin, 1977), 426-29. In Gabon there exists a
critical study: Dieudonné Lendoye Ringue, "Aperçu critique
de l'oeuvre scientifique d'André Raponda-Walker," (Mémoire
de maîtrise, UNOB, 1990).
6.
"Old scrappers" is a term used by Jacob Carruthers in referring to the
first Black American writers to write on Ancient Egypt who, though having
no formal training in history, fought to present a Black American perspective
on the past. See Carruthers, Essays in Ancient Egyptian Studies (Los
Angeles, 1984), 34-35.
7.
Pounah's books include Notre passé (Paris, 1967); Concept
gabonais. (Monaco, 1968); Carrefour de la discussion (Coulonges-sur-I'Autize,
197 1); and a French translation of Pasteur Ogoula Mbeye's Galwa manuscript,
Galoa ou Edongo d'antan (Fontenay-le-Comte, 1978). There is a brief
biographical note in Gardinier, Historical Dictionary, 165.
8.Sebastian
Bodinga-bwa-Bodinga, Traditions orales de la race Eviya (Paris,
1969).
9.In
addition to his book on Gabonese oral traditions, see Deschamps, Quinze
ans de Gabon
(Paris,
1965) and the list of books opposite the title page of Traditions orales
10.
Joseph Ambouroue-Avaro, Un peuple gabonais à l’aube de la colonisation
(Paris,
1981).
11.
For biographical information see Gaston Nwendogo's preface to Un peuple
gabonais, 13-19.
12.
See Nicolas Metegue N'nah, "Le Gabon de 1854 à 1886: 'Presence'
française et peuples autochtones" (Doctorat de 3e cycle, Université
de Paris 1, 1974); Economies et sociétés au Gabon dans
la première moitié du XIXe siécle (Paris, 1979);
Domination coloniale au Gabon: la résistance d'un peuple (Paris,
198 1); and the 1984 collection of essays, Lumiére sur points
d'ombre.
13.
In November 1981 the Mouvement de redressement national (MORENA) distributed
tracts throughout Libreville criticizing the Bongo regime and a number
of prominent politicians, academics, and journalists were arrested and
imprisoned. See Amnesty International's report, Gabon: Déni de
justice au cours d'un procés (London, 1984), 10-16.
14.
See Anges Ratanga-Atoz, "Les résistances gabonaises à l'impérialisme
de 1870 à 1914," (Doctorat en histoire, EPHE-Paris, 1973); "Fang
et Miéné dans le Gabon du XIXe siécle," Realités
gabonaises 38 (1977), 9-19; "Commerce, économie et société
dans le Gabon du XIXe-début XXe siécle," Annales de l'école
nationale d'administration (Libreville) 3 (1979), 85-96; "L'Immigration
Fang, ses origines et ses conséquences,"
Afrika Zamani 14/15
(1984), 7381; and Histoire du Gabon des migrations historiques à
la République XVe-XXe siécle(Paris, 1985). It would appear
that there is little love lost between Ratanga-Atoz and Metegue N'nah;
when referring to Ratanga-Atoz in his doctoral thesis Metegue N'nah puts
the word "historien" in quotation marks (Metegue N'nah, "Le Gabon," 135);
meanwhile, none of Metegue N'nah's works are referenced in Ratanga-Atoz's
Histoire
du Gabon. Such mutual dislike is not so surprising given their two
radically different relationships with the Bongo regime.
15.
See Florent Mbumb-Bwas, "Genése de l’Église du Gabon: étude
historique et canonique," (Doctorat d'université, Université
de Strasbourg, 1972) and (with Wisi MagangMa-Mbuju) Les Bajag du Gabon
(Paris, 1974). In the mid-1980s Digombe participated in some archeological
research; see Lazare Digombe et at, "Recherches archéologiques au
Gabon: Année académique 1986-1987," Nsi 2 (1987), 29-31;
and "Early Iron Age Prehistory in Gabon," Current Anthropology 29
(1988), 180-84.
16.
This was the situation, at least, when I met with Metegue N'nah in June
1989.
17.
The case of the geographer Marc Ropivia is revealing; Ropivia received
his academic training in Canada and has published historical articles on
the Fang migration (see Marc Ropivia, "Les Fangs dans les Grands Lacs et
la vallée du Nil," Présence africaine 120[1981], 46-58;
and "Migration Bantu et Tradition orale des Fang (le Mvett): Interprétation
critique," Le mois en Afrique 211/212 [1983], 121-32). He was an
outspoken critic of the government and the head of the Gabonese university
faculty union during the period of political turmoil at the beginning of
1990. Following the National Conference and the opening up of the Gabonese
political system, he was named Minister of Education, as a member of an
opposition party, in Prime Minister Casmir Oyé Mba's first cabinet.
Yet he quickly became embroiled in ongoing conflicts between his former
colleagues and the government. Tracts criticizing his handling of the situation
and, interestingly, mocking his Canadian (as opposed to French) doctoral
training circulated at the university early in 1991. UNOB was shut down
by a faculty strike in April and, in a subsequent cabinet reorganization,
Ropivia was replaced and effectively neutralized as a political force.
18.
On nationalist culture and universities, see Benedict Anderson, Imagined
Communities (London, 1991), 70-71.
19.
Most Gabonese researchers, whether student or faculty, use the library
facilities at the Bibliothèque Nationale (see below). When it was
functioning, the main library at UNOB was open Monday thru Friday, 9:OOAM-6:OOPM;
Saturday, 9:30AM-noon; admission open to the public; student ID needed
to consult materials. The UNOB history department library was open Monday,
Tuesday, 10:00AM-noon; 3:OOPM-6:OOPM; Wednesday thru Friday, 9:OOAM-noon;
3:OOPM-6:OOPM; Saturday, 8:OOAM-noon.
20.
Doctoral research since 1975 has been directed by Jean-Louis Miège
at Aix-Marseille I (5 theses); Annie Rey-Goldzeiger at Reims (4 theses);
Catherine Coquery-Vidrovitch at Paris VII (3 theses); Yves Person at Paris
1 (2 theses); M. Epp at Strasbourg II (1 thesis); Jean Devisse at Paris
I (I thesis); and Claude Hélène Perrot at Paris I (I thesis)
(Source: Repertoire des théses africanistesfrançaises
1978-1989)
21.
C. Felix Pambo-Loueya, "La colonie du Gabon de 1914 à 1939. Étude
economique et sociale," (Doctorat de 3e cycle, Université de Paris
VII, 1980).
22.
Examples would be Christian Mamfoumbi, "Contribution à l'étude
du travail forcé en Afrique équatoriale française
dans l'entre-deux-guerres (1914-1939): l'exemple du Gabon," (Doctorat de
3e cycle, Université de Paris 1, 1984); and Théophile Loungou-Mouélé,
"Le Gabon de 1910 à 1925: les incidences de la Première Guerre
mondiale sur I'évolution politique, économique et sociale,"
(Doctorat de 3e cycle, Université d'Aix-Marseille 1, 1984). Both
Mamfoumbi and Loungou-Mouélé assumed positions in the UNOB
history department on returning to Gabon. Loungou-Mouélé
was among a team of UNOB scholars who produced a short volume to mark the
town of Lastoursville's centenary, Millenaire de Mulundu: Centenaire
de Lastoursville.(Ubreville, 1986).
23.
Monique Koumba-Manfoumbi, "Les Punu du Gabon: Des origines à 1899,"
(Doctorat de 3e cycle, Université de Paris 1, 1987). It is significant
that Claude-Héléne Perrot, a specialist in oral history,
directed Koumba-Manfoumbi's research.
24.
For the obstacles she faced in gathering oral data, see Koumba-Manfoumbi,
"Les Punu," 5-8. Due to the unrest at UNOB during my stay in Gabon it was
extremely difficult to track down and meet with Gabonese historians. For
example, despite several efforts to contact her, I was unable to meet with
Koumba-Manfoumbi. I was told that in addition to being a member of the
UNOB history department, she also has an important administrative position
in the UNOB bureaucracy.
25.
Below is a list of other doctorats de 3e cycle completed in history at
French universities by this second generation of Gabonese researchers:
Jean-Pierre Elelaghe, "De l’aliénation à I'authenticité.
Problématique rnissionnaire et affrontements culturels au Gabon.
L'exemple des Fang," (Université de Strasbourg 11, 1977); Jean N'Doume-Assebe,
"L'enseignement missionnaire au Gabon (1842-1960)," (Université
de Paris 1, 1979); Mdfse-Nsole Biteghe, "Les relations franco-gabonaises
depuis 1960," (Université de Paris 1, 1981); Michel Renwomby, "La
politique administrative de la France an Gabon et ses conséquences
de 1899 à 1934," (Université d'Aix-Marseille 1, 1982); Jérôme
Mikal-Mi-Mikal, "L'enseignement au Gabon de 1842 à 1920," (Université
de Reims, 1983); Anselme Nzoghe, "L'exploitation forestière et les
conditions d'exploitation des peuples de la colonie du Gabon de 1920 à
1940: le travail forcé," (Université d'Aix-Marseille 1, 1984);
Hilaire Jidy Makaya, "Contribution à l'étude de la santé
en AEF: médecines traditionnelle et occidentale. Le cas du Gabon
(1910-1945)," (Université de Reims, 1984); Juste-Roger Koumabila,
"La guerre de Wongo au Gabon (1928-1930)," (Université de Paris
VII, 1984); Clotaire Ivala, "Structures monétaires et changements
économiques et sociaux an Gabon (1914-1960)," (Université
de Reims, 1985); Rose Ahavi, "Les bouleversements de la société
gabonaise au contact de l'Occident (1900-1939)," (Université d'Aix-Marseille
1, 1985); Charles Nziengui-Doukaga, "L'enseignement et la formation de
l'élite intellectuelle gabonaise (1920-1970)," (Université
de Reims, 1986).
Of
the above, N'Doume-Assebe, Nsole Biteghe, Kournabila, and Nziengui-Doukaga
have had positions in the UNOB history department. Nsole Biteghe has
published a short book on the 1964 coup attempt against Gabon's first
president, Léon Mba, entitled, Echec aux militaires
au Gabon (Paris, 1990).
The
history department has also been the academic home of Jean-Emile Mbot,
a former Minister of Culture who holds a doctorat d'État in ethnology:
"Les fondements sociaux de l'éthnology en Afrique noire: les
peuples du bassin de I'Ogooué de 1850 à nos jours," (DE,
Université de Paris V, 1979). See also his Ebughi bifia "Démonter
les expressions": Enonciation et situations sociales chez les Fang du
Gabon (Paris, 1975).
Finally,
a few Gabonese historians have studied in French-speaking Canada, although
they have not been nearly so numerous or influential as those who have
gone to France. For example, Pierre N'dombi, "Économies et sociétés
gabonaises avant la conquête coloniale," Thèse de maîtres
histoire, Université de Montréal, 1976); and, also from
the Université de Montréal, Nganga Akelaguelo, "Esquisse
d'histoire ethnique du Gabon," Présence africaine 132
(1984), 3-32.
26.
Interestingly, two key university figures in the political opposition,
Pierre-Louis Agondjo Okawe, the leader of the Parti Gabonais du Progrés,
and Max Remondo, the head of university faculty union during the 1991
strike actions, both produced law theses in the late 1960s that have
left their mark on Gabonese historical studies. See Pierre-Louis Agondjo
Okawe, "Structures parentales et développement au Gabon: les
Nkorni," (Thèse de Faculté de Droit et des Sciences économiques,
Université de Paris, 1967); and Max Remondo, 'L'organisation
administrative du Gabon de 1843 à nos jours," (Thèse de
Doctorat d'État de droit, Université de Paris, 1970).
27.
See Programme tradition orale: collecte, élaboration et publication
des traditions culturelles du Gabon (Libreville, 1987). A philosopher,
Benoit Mouity-Nzamba, was LUTO's first director. He was succeeded by
the sociologist Martin Alihanga, whose thèse dÉtat, 'Structures
communautaires traditionnelles et perspectives coopératives dans
la société alto-govéene (Gabon)," (Rome, Universario
Pontificale, 1975), is not only a classic example of the "ethnographic
account" genre (see below) but one of the more explicit attempts by
a Gabonese scholar to create a regional ethnic identity (the term "altogovéene"
is derived from "Haut-Ogooué", the name of the province in the
southeast corner of Gabon).
28.
See Revue Gabonaise des Sciences de I'Homme, Actes du seminaire de
formation en ethnomusicologie 1 (1988); and Actes du seminaire
des experts: Alphabet Scientifique des Langues du Gabon 2 (1990).
Voltz had the next five numbers of the Revue planned out, but
it is unlikely that these will be published in the near future. The
Histoire des villages du Gabon project was to be published in a series
of cahiers; the first two are on computer disk and await funding
for publication.
29.
Jean Bilinga et al, Le Gabon 1960-1980 (Libreville, 1981), 95-96.
30.
For an example see Loundou Mounanga, "L'exploitation de l'Or à Étéké(Gabon)
de 1937 à 1960," (Mémoire de licence, UNOB, 198 1).
31.
Conversations with Aliké Tshinyoka, head of UNOB history department
in April 1991.
32.
Her initial study is an example of mission history: Monique Koumba-Manfoumbi,
"La mission catholique Saint Martin des Apindji (1900-1954): étude
de cas sur l'histoire de l’évangélisation du Gabon," (Mémoire
de maîtrise, UNOB, 1983).
33.
Wilson-André Ndombet, "Histoire des Adjumba: la fin d'un peuple,"
(mémoire de licence, UNOB, 1983); "Histoire des Adjumba," (Mémoire
de maîtrise, UNOB, 1984); "Histoire des Ajumba du Gabon du XVe siécle
à 1972," Thése pour le nouveau doctorat de l'université,
Université de Paris 1, 1989).
34.
See Catherine Coquery-Vidrovitch, "A propos de 'La pensée de Cheikh
Anta Diop" d'Alain Froment," Cahiers dbudes africaines 32(1992),
135, for a criticism of this state of affairs.
35.
Ile Congrégation du Saint-Esprit was the dominant Catholic missionary
presence in colonial Gabon; historical documents relating to Gabon are
housed in the order's Archives Générales, 12, rue du Pére
Mazurie, 94669 Chevilly-Larue, France.
36.
Mathias Mbigui, "Recherches sur lbistoire de Sindara (1858-1946)," (Mémoire
de maltrise, UNOB, 1984) and Eugenie Mouanga-Mouloungui, "Contribution
A lhistoire de Mouila des origines i 1971," (Mémoire de maîtrise,
UNOB, 1984) are two good examples.
37.
Thirty years ago there remained but two Adjumba villages (see Raponda-Walker,
Notes, 60) and at present there exists only one Eviya village.
In addition to Ndombet's work on the Adjumba, there is J. M. Mackaya-Mackanga,
"Ethno-histoire des Ajumba: essai sur l'implantation des peuples du
Gabon des origines à l'indépendence," (Mémoire
de maîtrise, UNOB, 1983). For the Eviya, Léonard Diderot
Moutsinga Kebila, "Contribution à histoire Eviya," (Mémoire
de maîtrise, UNOB, 1989). Other "vanishing" peoples who have been
the subject of mémoires de maîtrise are the Benga, the
Varama, the Seki, and the Apindji (see appendix). The evolution of Gabonese
ethnic identity is the focus of my own research; see Christopher Gray,
"Space, Ethnicity, and Colonial Rule in Southern Gabon, 1858-1940,"
(Ph.D., Indiana University, 1994).
38.
Charles Mombo-Maganga, "Un siécle d'histoire Varama: seconde
moitié du 19e siécle, première moitié du
20e siécle," (Mémoire de matrise, UNOB, 1986).
39.
Mombo-Maganga, "Naissance et développement du pouvoir Gimondu
chez les Varama au 15e siécle," (Rapport de DEA, Université
de Montpellier 111, 1987).
40.
Jan Vansina, "The Ethnographic Account as a Genre in Central Africa," Paideuma
33
(1987), 433-44.
41.
Ibid., 434.
42.
Mayer has published a useful inventory of migration accounts found in
student research and has drawn extensively from mémoires de maîtrise
in a recent historical study of the Gabonese family. See Raymond Mayer,
"Inventaire et recension de 130 récits migratoires originaux
du Gabon," Pholia 4 (1989), 171-216; and Mayer, Histoire de
la famille gabonaise (Libreville, 1992).
43.
Inevitably, students complain of the difficulties in doing oral research
in Gabon. Information about clan origins, initiation societies, and the
past in general remains sensitive in a village setting and informants are
not quick to open up to young university students who, despite their linguistic
and cultural knowledge, may be as alien to village and clan elders as the
foreign researcher. This point was made clear to me in conversations with
Pére Ghislain Mwanda, a Gabonese priest based in Mouila, who stated
that university students often behave "comme les blancs" when they arrive
in villages to gather oral testimony and thus provoke the suspicions of
their informants (Interview Notes, VII, Pére Mwanda Ghislain, 27
September 1991).
44.
Hortense Togo, "La tradition orale des Apindji (Ngounié, Gabon):
Origines du peuple, mode de vie, médecine, religion et ethique,"
(Mémoire de mattrise, UNOB, 1988).
45.
Deschamps, Traditions orales 143-55.
46.
Henry H. Bucher, "Archival Resources in Gabon," History in Africa 1
(1974),
159-60.
47.
For the Ngounié and Nyanga provinces, documents have been transported
and classified for the administrative posts of Mbigou, Tchibanga, Moabi,
and Ndende. However, in Mouila, where there exist both regional and
district archives from the colonial period, documents dating from the
1930s to independence sit pell-mell on shelves of no use to researchers.
In Fougamou, the district archives are stored in a blockhouse behind
the prefecture. When I consulted them in June 1991, we had to clear
a path through tall grass to reach the blockhouse; the inside was musty
with piles of documents stacked to the ceiling, prey to mice and insects,
and waiting to tumble down on the researcher courageous enough to sort
through them. A quick perusal revealed interesting material on the logging
industry in the 1950s, but there are no funds available to protect or
classify these documents; the Gabonese bureaucrats in Fougamou expressed
regret about this situation but explained that they had more pressing
problems. In Mimongo all colonial archival material was lost in a fire.
By consulting Deschamps' 1962 inventory for these posts (Deschamps,
Traditions orales, 149-50), one sadly notes that valuable documents
have either been lost or remain inaccessible to researchers. There exists
a relevant mémoire: Thomas Nguema-Ndong, "Repertoire analytique
des principales sources historiques conservées au Gabon: des
origines jusqu'à 1900," (Mémoire de maltrise, UNOB, 1984).
48.
Among the different A.E.F. "séries" now available on
microfilm are Série B Correspondence Générale,
sous-série 2B "correspondence ancienne 1848-1912." Série
D Politique et Administration Générale, sous-série
4 (1) D "Rapports politiques- Gabon 1894-1945"; and sous-série
5D "Dossiers divers des Affaires politiques 1901-1956."
49.
Marchés
Tropicaux (20 April 1990), 1090.
50.
Howard Anderson, "The Limits of Development Management: An Analysis
of Agricultural Policy Implementation in Gabon" (Ph.D., Indiana University,
1987).
5
1. Marchis Tropicaux (11 September 1992), 2366-67; (29 January
1993), 284. See also my discussion of CICIBA in Chris Gray, Conceptions
of History in the Works of Cheikh Anta Diop and Thgophile Obenga (London,
1989), 76-78; 105-06.
52.
Annie Merlet, Ligendes et histoire des Mygng de 1'Ogooué (Libreville,
1989); Le pays des trois estuaires (Libreville, 1990); Vers
les plateaux de Masuku (Libreville, 1990); and Autour du Loango
(Libreville, 1991). These books were published jointly by the Centre
Culturel Franqais Saint-Exupéry in Libreville and Sépia
publications in Paris. They are useful in that they allow easy access
to historical information from early explorers like Robert Bruce Walker
(André Raponda-Walker's father) and Paul Du Chaillu, as well
as colonial figures like Brazza, Léon Guiral, Alfred Fourneau,
and George Le Testu. In each volume Merlet provides introductory comments
to the excerpted texts found in the second section of the books; as
Merlet is a documentalist and not a trained historian her analysis is
not particularly probing. For example, she does not subject the ethnic
categories used by European explorers and administrators to critical
scrutiny. The excerpted material is well-chosen, but page citations
to the original publications are not given. Despite these shortcomings
Merlet has performed a valuable service in gathering together a number
of important sources in Gabonese history and making them available to
a wider audience. The bibliographies to each book indicate the sources
available in the "Fonds Gabon" and thus allow the researcher to get
an idea of the scope of the collection.
Appendix:
Mémoires de Maîtrises in Gabonese History done at
the
Université National Omar Bongo (Libreville), 1982-1991
Historiography
Nguema-Ndong,
Thomas. "Repertoire analytique des principales sources historiques conservées
au Gabon: des origines jusqu'à 1900." 1984.
Archeology
and Material Culture
Asseko-Ndong,
Alain. "Essai d'une approche ethnoarchéologique sur la métallurgie
du fer dans la Province du Woleu-Ntem." 1988.
Issembe,
Aristide. "Les industries traditionnelles des métaux." 1984.
Kogou-Mboula,
Hortense. "Inventaire des sites archéologiques dans le département
de la Lébombi-Leyou (Moanda) Haut-Ogooué." 1985.
Riohou,
Ide Nestor. "La matière première dans l'industrie lithique
préhistorique de la Ngounie et de la Nyanga." 1990.
Colonial
Administration
Adze,
Léon-Paul. "Le régime de l'indigenat au Gabon de 1910
à 1946." 1985.
Anvame,
Olga-Chantal. 'Vaction des organismes financiers dans le développement
économique du Gabon (1944-1960)." 1990.
Barbera,
Max-Alain. "La perception de l'impôt au Gabon 1900-1930." 1989.
Didzambo,
Rufin.
"Migrations de travail au Gabon, 1900-1930." 1990.
Kiki,
Jeanne- Françoise. "La justice indigène au Gabon de 1910 à
1945."
1985.
Loubamono-Bessacque,
Guy-Claver. "L'armée coloniale au Gabon de 1910 à 1930."
1984.
Makongo,
Rene. "L'histoire économique du Gabon." 1983.
Mboumbou-Makanga,
Jean-Marie. "Main d'oeuvre autochtone et mise en valeur coloniale: exemple
du Gabon de 1900 à 1939." 1985.
Menie-Nka,
Théophile. "La Securité Sociale dans le Gabon colonial, 1918-1960."
1984.
Meviane,
Yolande-Christiane. "Les voies de communications au Gabon pendant la période
coloniale (1920-1960)." 1985.
Momha,
Roland. "Le Gabon de 1850 à 1929: commerce colonial et société
autoclitone." 1986.
Ngoua,
Philomène. "Les problèmes de santé au Gabon pendant
la période coloniale 1910-1955." 1984.
Nguema,
Marie-Thérèse. "L'oeuvre économique et sociale
des premières assemblées gabonaises: conseil représentatif
et assemblée territoriale, 1947-1960." 1986.
Nzengue,
Dieudonné. "Histoire de l'administration publique au Gabon de
1946 à 1958." 1988.
Rossinga,
Marie- Madeleine. "Contribution à l'étude de l'évolution
du patrimoine forestier gabonais: la première zone forestière
de 1946 à 1961." 1984.
Ethnic
Group History
Angue-Biyogho,
Brigitte. "Les razzias fang chez les Nturnu: Obane et Sono dans la région
Sud Cameroun et Nord Gabon de 1880 à 1950." 1989.
Binga,
Hubert. "Histoire de la chefferie Ndumu de 1879 - 1958." 1989.
Engone-Ndong,
Callixte. "Les Hausa d'Oyem des origines à nos jours (1899-1989)."
1991.
Goufoura-Offiga,
Antoinette. "Recherches sur le rôle de la chefferie indigéne
Gisira dans I'administration coloniale française de la
Ngounie (1909-1960)." 1985.
Ivanga,
François de Paul. "Contribution à l'histoire des Mpongwe
des origines à 1845." 1985.
Lekogo,
Thomas. "Economie coloniale et société precapitaliste
Mbere dans le Haut-Ogooué, 1875-1930." 1986.
Mackaya-Mackanga,
J.M. "Ethno-histoire des Ajurnba: essai sur l'implantation des peuples
du Gabon des origines a l'indépendence."
1983.
Madoungou-Boudianga,
Jean-Pierre. "Histoire de la région des Duma de 1882 à
1953: la domination coloniale et ses incidences." 1986.
Mezui-Me-Zue,
Celestin. "Société et économie des Fang du Nord
Gabon avant la colonisation, fin du 19e siècle." 1983.
Mombey,
Paul. "Les Benga, peuple du Gabon." 1988.
Mombo-Maganga,
Charles. "Un siècle d'histoire Varama: seconde moitié
du 19e siécle, premiére moitié du 20e siécle."
1986.
Mouloungui-Mouele.
"Esquisse d'étude monographique sur une ethnie gabonaise: le
cas des Sangu dans le 19e siècle." 1983.
Moutete,
Barthélemy. "Contribution à I'histoire do Gabon: les Wandjis
des origines é 1929." 1984.
Moutsinga
Kebila, Léonard Diderot. "Contribution à l'histoire Eviya."
1989.
M'Voubou,
Augustin. "Le peuple Punu du bassin de la Nyanga: les aspects socio-culturels
et leur évolution de la fin du XlXe siécle à l'indépendence."
1987.
Ndimina
Mougala, Antoine Denis "Monographie d'une ethnie gabonaise: les Gisir
de 1855 à 1900." 1983.
Ndombet,
Wilson-André. "Histoire des Adjumba." 1984.
Ndong
Bibang, Alfred Georges. "L'armement Ntumu son évolution des origines
à 1960." 1990.
Ngomo,
Théophile. "Contribution à l'histoire des Tsengi." 1984.
Nkala,
Simon. "Contribution à I'histoire de l'implantation des Fang
Nzaman dans I'Ogooué-Ivindo du siècIe dernier à
nos jours." 1986.
Nziengui-Moukani,
Jerome. "Histoire des implantations Bavungu dans la région du sud-ouest
do Gabon: des origines à 1968." 1988.
Obouyou
Makassi, Christian. "Ethno-histoire de la société Seki précoloniale:
migrations et structures traditionnelles." 1983.
Olaghe
Nkora, Noël "L'implantation et l'expansion du bwiti chez les Nzaman
de l'Ogooué-Ivindo de 1950 à nos jours." 1989
Togo,
Hortense. "La tradition orale des Apindji (Ngounie, Gabon): origines
du peuple, mode de vie, médecine, religion et éthique."
1988.
Town
and Regional Histories
Akendengue,
Bernard. "La vie économique et sociale dans le district d'Omboué,
1945-1960." 1986.
Ayingone
Eyi, Blandine. "Famines, épidémies au Woleu-Ntem pendant
la période coloniale de 1910 à 1960." 1985.
Banguebe,
Benjamin. "La vie économique et sociale à Lastoursville de
1883 à 1928." 1989.
Codjo,
Leopold. "L'évolution économique de I'Ogooué- Maritime
de 1930 à 1960." 1984.
Dzimet
Mba, Rufin. "L'évolution de Cocobeach des origines à nos
jours." 1987.
Eya-Minko,
Fidele. "Les échanges commerciaux entre les provinces du Woleu-Ntem
(Gabon) et les provinces du Centre-Sud (Cameroun) de 1945 à 1960."
1987.
Leoumbou,
Scholastique-Rufine. "Contribution à I'histoire de la ville de Franceville
de 1880 à 1946." 1985.
Lepebe,
Jean. "Occupation coloniale française dans le Haut-Ogooué
(Gabon) 1880-1946. 1985.
Magandi,
Christian. "Ogooué-Maritime: les incidences de l'exploitation
et de l'exploration du pétrole sur le peuplement actuel (1928-1985)."
1990.
Mba-Biyogho,
Jean-Paul. "La colonisation do Nord-Gabon (Woleu-Ntem) de 1902 à
1932." 1985.
Mbanga
Livoua, Barnabé José. "Fleuve et sociétés:
le cas de I'Ogooué au Gabon, des origines à 1973." 1990.
Mbigui,
Mathias. "Recherches sur histoire de Sindara (1858-1946)." 1984.
Meye,
François-Charles. "La fondation de Madiville 1883 (futur Lastoursville)."
1985.
Meye-Me-Nze,
François. "Évolution de la vie politique dans la région
du Woleu-Ntem (1945-1960)." 1985.
Meyo-Me-Nkoghe,
Dieudonné. "La vie économique et sociale de Kango de 1900
à 1955." 1989.
Mouanga-Mouloungui,
Eugenie. "Contribution à I'histoire de Mouila des origines à
1971." 1984.
Ndong-Ondo,
Jean-Fréderic. "La mise en valeur économique de la région
du Woleu-Ntem: 1900-1950." 1986.
Ndoutoume-Minko,
Thomas. "L'activité économique et commerciale dans la région
de I'Ogooué-Ivindo pendant la période coloniale: 1905-1960."
1986.
Ngolet,
Francois. "Techniques et activités cynégétiques
dans le Moyen-Ogooué précolonial (Gabon): approche photohistorique
et paléosociologique." 1986.
Ngonda,
Fabien. "Les exploitations diamentifères de Makongonio 1947-1958:
étude économique et sociale." 1983.
Ngoubili,
Felicité. "Recherches sur I'histoire de la frontiére nationale
entre le Gabon et le Congo: le secteur de la Nyanga de 1934 à 1979."
1984.
Nguema-Edzo,
Michel. "L'évolution historique de Ntoum de 1905 à 1970."
1985.
Nkeze
Igouwe, Edwige. "La vie politique et syndicale dans I'Ogooué-Maritime
de 1945 à 1960."
1983.
Nze,
Samuel. "L'évolution économique de la région du Moyen-Ogooué
de 1862 à 1960." 1983.
Nzeong-Mbami,
Paulin. "La vie politique et éconornique dans la région
de I'Ogouué-Ivindo: de la colonisation à l'indépendence
1945-1960." 1985.
Nzetchouang,
Bernadette. "Les relations économiques entre le Sud-Cameroun
et le Nord-Gabon de 1919 à 1950." 1986.
Obame-Anda,
Paulin. "L'histoire de Bitam, 1904-1960." 1986.
Obiang,
Claude L. "Implantation européene et domination française
sur 'arongo mbe ndiwa' ou les côtes de I'Estuaire de Gabon 1828-1888."
1985.
Omvane-Nkouele,
Francois-Xavier. "Oyem des origines à 1960: évolution
économique, politique et sociale." 1986.
Catholic
Mission Histories
Bé
Ndong, Albert-Simon. "Missions chrétiennes du Woleu-Ntem: cas
du departement de Ntem." 1990.
Delicat,
Cherubin. "La mission catholique de Mayumba, 1888 à 1958." 1984.
Koumba
Manfoumbi, Monique. "La mission catholique Saint Martin des Apindji
(1900-1954): étude de cas sur I'histoire de l'évangélisation
du Gabon." 1983.
Lendoye
Ringue, Dieudonné. "Aperçu critique de l'oeuvre scientifique
d'André Raponda-Walker." 1990.
Ngoma-Tchikaya,
Joseph. "La vie et l'oeuvre de Monseigneur Jean-Remy Bessieux au Gabon
(1803-1876)." 1985.
Obiang-Nguema,
Dieudonné. "La Mission Sainte Thérèse d'Oyem de
1929 à 1979." 1985.
Ogowet,
Thérèse. "La Mission Saint Louis de Port-Gentil de 1927
à 1971." 1986.
Olla,
Jacqueline. "Sainte-Anne d'Odimba (1887-1960): oeuvre missionnaire et rayonnement."
1983.
Oyandja,
Dieudonné. "La mission catholique Saint Hilaire de Franceville de
1897 à 1970." 1986.
Islam
in Gabon
Assournou
Mombey, Théophile. "L'évolution de l'islam au Gabon de
1973 à nos jours." 1989.
Nzeng,
Armand. "Essai sur l'histoire de l'islam à Libreville de 1900
à nos jours." 1985.
Independence Era
Bitoung
Angome, Michèle Nathalie Chanique. "De la libre circulation des
personnes et des biens dans le système de l'UDEAC de 1964 à
1985: cas de relations Gabon-Camerounaises." 1990.
Eyindanga,
Edouard Jacob. "Les langues do marché à Libreville." 1989.
Nziengui,
Charles. "L'enseignement au Gabon 1960-1970." 1982.